Harry Potter and the …School of Witchcraft without Wiccans??

jktweet

J.K. Rowling frequently treats fans to explanations and back-stories to the world of witchcraft she has created in Harry Potter through her official website Pottermore and her Twitter account. But last week she dropped a bit of a bombshell when she tweeted: “To everyone asking whether their religion/belief/non-belief system is represented at Hogwarts: the only people I never imagined there are Wiccans.”

As both a long-time fan of the Harry Potter series and as an Eclectic Pagan influenced by Wicca, I have a problem with this tweet. It seems utterly unnecessary to say such a thing that is inevitably going to make some of her Wiccan fans feel alienated. She later explained that Wiccan magic is somehow not compatible with the magic of Hogwarts, but this has a rather hollow ring. There are plenty of other religions that have magical elements to them (including Judaism, which J.K. Rowling categorically stated is represented in the student body of Hogwarts), and much of the magic in Harry Potter is clearly inspired by Wicca and related living witchcraft.

This tweet is also very dismissive when bearing in mind how loyal Rowling’s Wiccan fanbase has been. Let’s not forget that she came under a lot of fire from conservative Christians for writing children’s books featuring witchcraft. Many Wiccans, on the other hand, love her series (I even featured Harry Potter in my list of top 10 Wiccan movies for children!), and I know from personal experience that she inspired a generation of young people to gain a serious interest in magic and witchcraft. It therefore strikes me as insensitive, if not downright mean-spirited, to say that Wiccans are not represented among the students of Hogwarts.

Finally, I find it very sad that J.K. Rowling has been so quick to exclude Wiccans from her world when she has famously stood up for marginalised communities in her writing. Even when it meant incurring the wrath of those who disagreed with her, she has given a voice to the LGBT community, immigrants, victims of abuse, the disabled, the impoverished, and even criminals. Why, therefore, has she stated that Wiccans don’t belong at Hogwarts? Wiccans and other practitioners of witchcraft have faced persecution for hundreds of years now, and even today a great number feel the need to conceal their religion from others out of fear of misunderstanding and discrimination. It feels like being kicked when you’re already down when the famous champion of victimised minority groups doesn’t make you feel welcome!

The only reason I can think of for J.K. Rowling to say such a thing is to be “ironic,” without really thinking through how it might make her Wiccan fans feel, or because she lacks an understanding of what Wicca really is – does she somehow think that Wiccans wouldn’t want to be at Hogwarts for religious reasons? Because in my experience that’s not the case at all.

So let me be clear now – J.K. Rowling, you do have many Wiccan fans who have taken a lot of pleasure and comfort in your representation of a world where magic has a place, and many of them have been left puzzled and saddened by your throw-away comment on the lack of Wiccans at Hogwarts. Please think more carefully about how your words may make your fans feel in the future.

Advertisements

3 Comments

Filed under Art & Expression

3 responses to “Harry Potter and the …School of Witchcraft without Wiccans??

  1. I’ve always been under the impression that there was a lot of anxiety that she was promoting real Witchcraft, and she has had to be very clear in dealing with her detractors that she is not trying to convert children. Plus I know there was some criticism from Wiccans about how her books gave an unrealistic portrayal of Witchcraft–which always made me groan because at least it was a POSITIVE portrayal, lol. I think you are right, though, that it could have been handled a little more delicately. Since she has always been sensitive to not marginalizing groups or pre-judging individuals, a simple, “People of all races, genders, sexual orientations, and religions are all represented by the student body of Hogwarts,” would have kept us from being, once again, rejected, and still kept the issue of religion neutral.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s